#704
Imagine this: A visionary founder sparks a revolution. He builds an empire on bold ideas – innovation, self-reliance, and a fierce rejection of the status quo. But as the movement swells beyond his control, the very creation he birthed turns on him. He gets ousted, not out of malice, but necessity. The company – Apple – thrives without him, only for Steve Jobs to return years later, humbled and wiser.
Now fast-forward to today. Donald J. Trump, the brash real estate mogul turned political disruptor, founded MAGA – Make America Great Again – in much the same way. It wasn't just a slogan; it was a clarion call for economic revival, manufacturing independence, technological prowess, and a foreign policy that puts America first, not last in endless global entanglements. Like Apple's garage origins, MAGA started small but exploded into a cultural and electoral force. And like Apple in the late 1980s, when Jobs' ego clashed with the board's vision, MAGA now seems to have outgrown its founder. Ten months into Trump's second term, the groundswell that propelled him to victory is rumbling with disillusionment. The movement demands evolution; Trump must listen, or risk a Jobs-like exile – not from a boardroom, but from the base he built.
This isn't hyperbole. It's a tale of triumph turned tension, drawn from the raw pulse of American politics. For my global readers – from London to Lahore – think of MAGA as a populist uprising akin to Brexit or Modi's early attempt of economic reforms: a rejection of elites, wrapped in nationalism. But unlike those, MAGA's DNA is anti-interventionist, pro-worker, and unapologetically isolationist on foreign shores. Trump's 2024 landslide – sweeping all seven swing states (Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin), securing 312 electoral votes, and clinching the popular vote with over 50% – was no fluke. It was powered by 75 million voters, foot soldiers like Cliff Maloney, Scott Presler, and Jack Posobiec who knocked on millions of doors, and high-profile converts: Charlie Kirk's Turning Point USA mobilizing youth, Elon Musk's X platform amplifying the message, Tucker Carlson's prime-time takedowns of the "deep state," Glenn Beck's media muscle, and Marjorie Taylor Greene's fiery congressional advocacy. Even the Senate flipped to a 53-47 Republican edge, giving Trump a slim but workable majority – enough for reconciliation bills to bypass the 60-vote filibuster filibuster, as the Founding Fathers intended for divided government.
Yet, as November 2025 dawns, hope is curdling into frustration. X (formerly Twitter) buzzes with raw vents: "MAGA is dead," declares far-right influencer Nick Fuentes, citing fresh Epstein revelations as the final straw. Polls show MAGA identification dipping from 52% post-election highs to 37% among core supporters, per Vanderbilt data, as unmet promises fester. Why? Let's dissect the fault lines, point by point, with the facts – and the counter-narratives – laid bare.
1. The Ukraine Quagmire: Sucked into the Swamp Trump Promised to Drain
MAGA's foreign policy north star? No more forever wars. End the meddling that bleeds American treasure for corrupt allies. Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022 fit the bill perfectly – a European mess, propped up by a military-industrial complex (MIC) addicted to endless arms sales. Trump's base cheered his 2017-2021 restraint; now, they're aghast as he waffles.
Ten months in, the war shows no end. Western media – from The Economist to The New York Times – peddle inflated Russian casualty figures (up to 4 million, with a 1:5 Ukraine-to-Russia kill ratio), but independent analysts like those at the Quincy Institute peg actual Russian losses closer to 500,000-600,000, with Ukrainian deaths nearing parity. Ukraine, a byword for corruption (siphoning billions in U.S. aid via Zelenskyy cronies), has become a black hole. Trump halted direct U.S. funding – a MAGA win – but the MIC reroutes weapons through Europe, keeping the pipeline fat.
Neocons like Lindsey Graham and Marco Rubio whisper hawkish nothings, ignoring ground realities Trump gleaned in a candid 90-minute Putin call. To his credit, Trump hosted Putin at the August 2025 Alaska Summit in Anchorage, yielding a fragile truce on energy exports. Progress stalled, but envoy Steve Witkoff's backchannel talks with Moscow – leaked this week – push a 28-point peace plan demanding Ukrainian territorial concessions (Crimea, Donbas) and demilitarization. Putin banks on Trump; MAGA wants bilateral U.S.-Russia thaw, letting "weak Europeans" foot their bill.
Counter-narrative: Hawks argue concessions betray Ukraine's sovereignty, painting Trump as Putin's puppet – a charge amplified by Democrats and even some GOP moderates. If the plan fails, blame could boomerang, eroding Trump's "peacemaker" cred.
2. Israel's Shadow: From Ally to Albatross
America First means no blank checks for foreign lobbies. Yet Israel's Gaza operations – now in year three – have morphed it into a global pariah. UN resolutions condemn settler violence; boycotts hit from soccer pitches to art stages; even mainstream Democrats label it "outside the tent." Casualties top 40,000 Palestinians; ICC warrants loom for Netanyahu.
Trump's shield – via AIPAC's $100M+ war chest – holds, but it's cracking MAGA down the middle. Pro-Israel diehards (e.g., evangelical base) clash with isolationists like Tucker Carlson, MTG, Rand Paul, and Thomas Massie, who decry "Zionism ≠ Judaism" (much like Hindutva ≠ Hinduism in India). Calling MTG a "traitor" alienates the grassroots.
A clear plan – two-state viability, aid conditions – could unify. But AIPAC's grip makes it "easier said than done."
Counter-narrative: Israel's defenders, including Trump loyalists, frame criticism as anti-Semitism, citing Hamas's October 7 atrocities (1,200 Israeli deaths). Polls show 60% of Republicans still back unconditional aid; peeling away evangelicals risks electoral suicide.
3. Epstein's Ghost: Transparency or Ticking Bomb?
The pedophile financier's files – a MAGA obsession since 2019 – exposed elite rot. Trump's initial foot-dragging divided the base; Fuentes' "MAGA is dead" tirade exploded on X after November 12 leaks implicating Trump in a 2011 Epstein encounter. Groundswell forced his hand: Yesterday, Trump signed a bill mandating DOJ release within 30 days, including unredacted client lists.
A post-Watergate-style commission? Essential – probing for five years beyond Trump's term to unearth truths without partisan theater.
Counter-narrative: Releases could boomerang, ensnaring Trump allies (or foes). Privacy advocates warn of vigilante justice; some MAGA skeptics see it as performative, delaying real swamp-draining.
4. H-1B Heartburn: Legal Migration's Hidden Sting
Illegals? Cracked down hard – border crossings down 80%, MAGA cheers. But legal visas like H-1B? They've gutted American tech jobs for 25 years, outsourcing to "third-world" talent at cut rates. Trump's Musk pivot – "H-1B is great!" – ignited fury. Bannon and MTG rage against the "visa scam"; Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy defend it for innovation.
Solution? A middle path: Caps tied to wage floors, apprenticeships for U.S. workers, audits on abuse. Balance business (Musk's Tesla needs coders) with nationalism (Bannon's "America for Americans").
Counter-narrative: Silicon Valley warns restrictions stifle growth; 70% of H-1Bs go to Indians, fueling "model minority" resentment. Trump's U-turn won tech donors but lost blue-collar trust.
5. Echoes of Empire: Iran, Venezuela, Cuba – Neocon Traps
No new wars – Trump's 2017 pledge. Yet threats mount: Strikes on Venezuelan "narco-boats" killed 83 since September, labeled drug ops but smelling of regime-change pretext against Maduro. Iran whispers of "maximum pressure 2.0"; Cuba and Nicaragua face sanctions revival. Deep state cabal (Rubio, Hegseth) pushes; one misstep, and war-crimes indictments loom – tarnishing Trump's "no-wars" legacy.
Counter-narrative: Admin claims strikes curb fentanyl (100k U.S. deaths/year); Maduro's Iran ties justify pressure. Polls show 55% GOP support for "tough" Latin America policy.
The Bigger Picture: MAHA Sabotage, Tariff Tangles, and Affordability Whiplash
It's not just foreign folly. RFK Jr.'s MAHA (Make America Healthy Again) – anti-pesticide, pro-vaccine transparency – faces HHS/EPA sabotage, undercutting Trump's "wild on health" vow. Tariffs? Poor rollout invites SCOTUS smackdown; oral arguments this week signal doubts on executive overreach, risking $195B in refunds and trade chaos. Affordability inches up (gas $2.80/gallon), but Trump's team botched messaging on Biden-era wreckage – no "auto-pen" explainer for the masses.
X echoes the malaise: From Fuentes' rage to weary vets decrying "disillusionment."
Recalibrate or Resign? The 12-Month Clock
Trump's salvation? Ditch the foreign jaunts; tour Rust Belt towns, heed truth-tellers like Carlson, Tulsi Gabbard, Musk (selectively), and Massie. Sideline CIA/FBI holdouts; wield that common sense that won 2024.
November 4, 2026, midterms loom – 12 months to course-correct. Ignore the swell, and history rhymes: Jobs fired in 1985, Apple soared. Trump could quit mid-term, the second POTUS to bow out – alarm bells toll.
For the world's sake – and America's – let's hope he pivots. MAGA isn't anti-Trump; it's pro-America. Time to let the movement lead.
God bless America – and may wisdom prevail.
What do you think? Has MAGA peaked, or is this just growing pains? Drop your takes below.
Karthik
20/11/25 10am.




















